The debate between washing and not washing PCBs post-assembly is a topic ripe with misconceptions. Adding to the complexity is the revolutionary role of no-clean flux, which has reshaped perceptions and practices within the industry. A deeper dive into instances where customers might mistakenly believe they need to wash their boards, despite it being unnecessary, can illuminate common pitfalls and help clarify best practices.

‍

Equating Residue with Dysfunction

One of the most common misunderstandings stems from the presence of residue on the PCB after soldering with no-clean flux. Unlike traditional fluxes that leave corrosive residues requiring removal, no-clean flux is designed to leave behind a minimal and non-conductive residue that doesn’t compromise the board's functionality or longevity. However, the sight of any residue can lead to the mistaken belief that it must be cleaned off to prevent damage or ensure proper functionality, overlooking the fact that no-clean residues are harmless in most applications. That being said, you’d be surprised how minimal the residue with modern no-clean flux can be. In fact, we recently had a customer think their boards had been washed due to how unnoticeable the no-clean residue was.

‍

Overestimating the Impact on Sensitive Components

Another scenario involves overestimating the impact of no-clean flux residues on sensitive components. While it's true that in highly sensitive applications (such as aerospace or medical devices), even the smallest amount of residue could potentially interfere with performance, for the vast majority of consumer electronics and general applications, the residue left by no-clean flux poses no threat. The misunderstanding lies in not recognizing the specific contexts that necessitate a completely residue-free environment, leading to unnecessary cleaning.

‍

Misinterpreting Regulatory and Standard Requirements

Regulatory and standard requirements can also be a source of confusion. Some manufacturers may mistakenly believe that all products must meet the same stringent cleanliness criteria applied in specific industries. While regulations like RoHS (Restriction of Hazardous Substances) and standards such as IPC A-610 do set forth requirements for PCB cleanliness, they are often misinterpreted to mean that all residues must be removed, disregarding the distinctions made for no-clean processes and the actual risk posed by residues.

‍

Navigating the Decision to Clean Your Circuit Boards

The introduction of no-clean flux technologies have undoubtedly minimized the need for post-assembly cleaning, offering a beacon of efficiency and reliability in many scenarios. However, the landscape of electronics manufacturing is vast and varied, with each application carving out its unique set of requirements and challenges.

Before leaning towards or away from washing your boards, consider the following points:

1. Assess the Application's Tolerance for Risk: High-reliability fields such as aerospace, medical devices, and military technology demand a zero-tolerance policy for potential failures. If your board falls into these categories, cleaning is less a choice and more a mandate for ensuring the highest standards of reliability and safety.
2. Understand the Environmental Conditions: Will your board be exposed to conditions that could compromise its integrity over time? If high humidity, temperature extremes, or exposure to corrosive substances is in your product’s future, washing could be a proactive step towards longevity and durability. If your board is expected to function in harsh environments like this, you may want to consider additional protection such as conformal coating or potting.
3. Evaluate the Cost-Benefit Ratio: The decision to clean also hinges on a pragmatic assessment of costs versus benefits. Consider the potential costs of cleaning (both financial and temporal) against the risk of failure or performance degradation. In some cases, the peace of mind offered by cleaning may well justify the investment.
4. Visual and Aesthetic Requirements: In some consumer electronics, the appearance of the PCB can be a factor in the overall product design, especially in transparent or open-case designs where the board is visible. Washing is employed not just for functional reasons but to meet aesthetic criteria as well.
5. Consult with Experts: When in doubt, seek guidance from those who tread these paths daily. Manufacturers can offer invaluable insights tailored to your specific scenario, helping demystify the complexities surrounding your decision.

‍

Deciding whether to wash circuit boards after assembly depends on many factors specific to each project. Consider your application's requirements, environmental factors, and compliance needs. Consulting with industry experts can also help. This approach ensures you make a well-informed choice that matches efficiency with quality and reliability.

‍

Interested in more content on cleaning? We have a couple podcast episodes on the topic 

CircuitHub - Ep. 23: Board Cleaning w/ Mike Konrad (part 1)

CircuitHub - Ep. 24: Board Cleaning w/ Mike Konrad (part 2)

CircuitHub - Ep. 59: Even Cleaner Cleaning With Cleaning Expert Mike “Mr. Clean” Konrad